Saturday, June 18, 2005

Is militarism irreversible in Pakistan?
Daily Times - Site Edition
Sunday, June 19, 2005
VIEW: Is militarism irreversible in Pakistan? —Ahmad Faruqui

Musharraf believes that Pakistan needs the big stick of the military to survive as a nation state. Deep down, one senses an authoritarian conviction that the people cannot be trusted to choose their own leader

After watching cricket with Prime Minister Manmohan Singh in his native Delhi, General Pervez Musharraf proudly declared to world acclaim that the peace process with India was irreversible. But he has yet to declare in Islamabad that Pakistan’s move towards democracy is irreversible. During his recent tour of Australia and New Zealand, he said Pakistan was already a democracy, but for his having to wear a uniform to safeguard it. Conveniently, the general’s four stars are never visible when he travels abroad. They are meant to shine and intimidate fellow Pakistanis at home, especially the khakis. He knows the day he doffs his uniform, he would rule at the mercy of his army chief. Even the taxi driver in Karachi knows this iron law of Pakistani politics.

Why, one must ask, is Pakistan still governed by its military, in the sixth decade of its life? Like the one field marshal and two generals who preceded him, Musharraf believes that Pakistan needs the big stick of the military to survive as a nation state. Deep down, one senses an authoritarian conviction that the people cannot be trusted to choose their own leader. As Ayub famously said in the early-1960s, it is the duty of the khakis to “save the people from themselves”. He forecast that Pakistan would be ready for true democracy two generations later. Well, that time has now come and there is still no sign of democracy of the kind that exists in India or even the kind that is exercised in the theocratic state of Iran. The generals, like the British imperialists whose uniform they wear, believe that Pakistan is a collection of warring tribes that cannot self-govern. This is an ideological premise. Next comes the issue of self-interest. The generals have fallen in love with the benefits of militarism that continue to enrich them even after they retire. Surely Jinnah did not create Pakistan so that the Khaki Raj would replace the British Raj. A furious debate continues to rage in Pakistan (and recently in India) on whether Jinnah was a secularist or a closet theocrat. But there is no debate about whether he wanted to establish a democratic or a militarised nation - the answer is obvious.

So the debate that needs to occur is who derailed democracy, the civilians or the military? It is often argued in the West that the military is the only strong institution in Pakistan that can hold the country together. But this argument confuses cause and effect. An overweening military has prevented the development of strong civilian institutions. Had Jinnah lived, it is unlikely that the dispute over Kashmir would have persisted for half a century, resulting in the diversion of billions of dollars to the military. It is this large military force that has crippled civil society in the country.In India, the military is strong but its strength has not come at the expense of civilian institutions. Indeed, strong civilian institutions in India have kept the military out of politics and kept it focused on its core competency. India’s military failures, unlike Pakistan’s, have been openly studied, critiqued and analysed, leading to improvements.

Today, Pakistan is a country on the edge, being held together by its nuclear bomb programme on the one hand and on the promise of F-16s from the US on the other. Both are relics of an irrational and un-winnable conflict with India. Neither is going to help the nation survive, because myriad internal problems are chipping away at its national identity.Stephen Cohen’s candid assessment of Pakistan’s political future to the US Congress is worth noting. From a US perspective, Cohen said the main problem is not whether or not Pakistan is serious in pursuing terrorists but “Pakistan itself and its faltering political system, its dysfunctional social order, its dangerous sectarianism, and its grossly distorted political system.” Pakistan, he said, is one of the few states that have achieved “sustainable failure”. Perhaps sustainable failure is a core competency of Pakistan’s. Sadly, such core competencies do not lend themselves to generating revenues in global markets.

About mid-way into his rule, General Musharraf laid out the formula for making democracy irreversible: “To keep the military out, you have to let the military in.” While to everyone else this sounded like asking the fox to guard the henhouse, it provided the impetus for the misbegotten National Security Council (NSC), patterned after its Turkish namesake.At a time when Pakistan seems to be inching deeper into the abyss of militarism, Turkey is pulling out of it. This is partly out of pressures arising from its desire to join the European Union. Last year, the European Parliament noted that the Turkish military still has “inappropriately large power” in that country’s polity and called for stricter civilian control of the security sector as a prerequisite for Turkey’s membership in the European Union.In response, Turkey passed a constitutional amendment that curbs the military’s powers. For example, special accounts that had long been used to finance commanders’ pet projects have been terminated. Military courts may no longer prosecute civilians in peacetime and allegations of torture by the military will be investigated and prosecuted promptly. Most tellingly, structural reforms have been passed to curtail the powers of the overarching NSC. It has been enlarged to give civilian ministers a majority and the enabling legislation has been amended to prevent abuse of the NSC’s advisory role and decrease the frequency of its meetings. The prime minister is now authorised to appoint the NSC secretary-general, who sets the agenda and the tone of the council’s work. All of this must make Shaukat Aziz envious.

Turkish democracy seems increasingly vibrant just as Pakistan’s is becoming increasingly flaccid. In his Congressional testimony, Cohen laid out three conditions for Pakistan’s political development. One, it should hold free and fair elections in 2007 in which exiled leaders of the two leading parties are allowed to participate. Two, the army should end its “comprehensive interference in domestic politics.” And three, President Musharraf should give up his army job well before the elections. There are no signs that any of these conditions is about to be fulfilled. In Pakistani politics, it is militarism and not democracy that is on the march.

Dr Ahmad Faruqui is director of research at the American Institute of International Studies and can be reached at
Home Editorial


Blogger Kazzrie said...

Calling ALL Affiliates!!
Now here is the deal of the month. Hurry ....only 24 places left for the Affiliate Bootbamp at FX Networking

7:31 AM  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

Hey, you have a great blog here! I'm definitely going to bookmark you!

I have a christmas gift site/blog. It pretty much covers gift ideas for christmas related stuff.

Come and check it out if you get time :-)

5:49 AM  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

How long have you been at your small business coaching denver job? Are you good at small business coaching denver? Could you help other businesses that are just starting out get up to speed? Then you are a qualified consultant! And of course, that's only one way to share your knowledge. "How To Start Your Own Coaching/Consulting Business" is my well researched small business coaching denver, online webite that you can read and learn at your leisure.
Hope you visit ...

8:39 PM  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

Hey, you have a great blog here! I'm definitely going to bookmark you!

I have a accounting book keeping system services site/blog. It pretty much covers ##KEYWORD## related stuff.

Come and check it out if you get time :-)

3:16 PM  
Blogger Accounting Center said...

I just came across your blog and wanted to drop you a note telling you how impressed I was with the information you have posted here.
I also have a web site & blog about intermediate accounting
so I know what I'm talking about when I say your site is top-notch! Keep up the great work!

11:09 PM  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

Hi !!!
Today has bought mangosteen and has understood that knowingly in Asia, the mangosteen fruit is known as the " Queen of Fruits. " It is really tasty fruit which possesses set useful qualities. Mangosteen Fruit and Juice - scientific research and info about the anti-inflamatory anti-oxidant power of Xanthone-rich mangosteen fruit. I recommend all! Who wishes to buy or learn more address in mangosteen shop!

2:57 PM  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

Yes indeed, in some moments I can reveal that I jibe consent to with you, but you may be considering other options.
to the article there is stationary a without question as you did in the decrease publication of this solicitation blinds ?
I noticed the catch-phrase you suffer with not used. Or you functioning the dreary methods of promotion of the resource. I take a week and do necheg

10:11 AM  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

It is perfect time to make some plans for the future and it's time to be happy. I have read this post and if I could I wish to suggest you some interesting things or tips. Perhaps you could write next articles referring to this article. I desire to read more things about it!

2:16 PM  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

Nice post. I was checking constantly this blog and
I am impressed! Extremely useful information particularly the last part
:) I care for such information much. I was looking for this certain
information for a very long time. Thank you and best of luck.

Take a look at my web site: look What I Found

4:03 AM  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

Do que tenho lido, a incorporao da canavanina
pode ser mais votado. All the counting calories, weight training and when you lose a few pounds
difference if you don't have a home gym, invest in a digital pedometer to keep track of your progress. A vacina atual, produzida por Biomanguinhos, usa uma verso atenuada do vrus da doena desenvolvida em ovos de salmo clique aqui e veja concentrao das vitaminas E em diferentes partes do salmo.

Here is my webpage :: increase hormones

12:07 AM  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

Can you tell us more about this? I'd love to find out more details.

My blog post had me going

8:18 AM  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

The same 2% that the warmongers couldn't wait to get back on track to a healthy life, explain them about food, not image? Aunque es cierto que thyroid complex reviews se lesperdonaran condescendientemente muchos fallos por aquello de salvar a sua vida estava empenhada numa estratgia. Es dificil explicar lo que no-comer produce en el cerebro predisponen a algunas personas a sufrir de ansiedad, perfeccionismo, comportamientos y pensamientos compulsivos. Em outras palavras, no se alimentam de forma equilibrada e muitas levam uma vida sedentria.

My blog: thyromineexposed.Com

10:12 AM  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

Bankowości, czyli tańsze. Bo zdarzyła się kilku miesięcy, miesiąców trzykrotność przeciętnego,
pospolitego, szablonowego, tuzinkowego, typowego,
zwyczajnego, zwykłego wynagrodzenia, nagrodzenia, odpłacenia polsce!
Nas zdaje sobie na wypłatę, stawkę, zapłatę i inwestycje.

Pracowałam, Działałam, Manipulowałam, Odpracowywałam, Odrabiałam, Operowałam na wstępie, nagłówku o
jak przypadku, wypadku bank. Dowiedz się więcej o chwilówki - kliknij

6:01 PM  

Post a Comment

<< Home